There are unique homes—and then there’s this place. Located in my hometown of Sheffield, Massachusetts, this 60-acre property is built around a limestone quarry that’s been turned into a private pool. It’s not a gimmick. It’s carved right into the land and framed by stone walls and a waterfall. And it’s just five minutes from both public and private schools, with Great Barrington up the road.
If you like privacy, quiet, and having a home that doesn’t look like everyone else’s, this place is worth a closer look.
About Sheffield, MA
Sheffield is a small town in the southern Berkshires—right on the Connecticut border, about 15 minutes from Great Barrington. You won’t find big box stores or traffic lights here, and that’s kind of the point. It’s mostly farmland, woods, and back roads. People here tend to know each other, and there’s a real mix of families who’ve been here forever and folks who moved up from the city.
The local public school, Mount Everett, is about 5 minutes from the property. Berkshire School, a top-tier private boarding school, is also just down the road. If you’re looking for a quiet place that still keeps you close to schools, groceries, and restaurants, this is a great spot.
The Main Feature: A Pool Built Into a Quarry
Let’s just start here, because this isn’t something you see every day. The pool is built right into an old limestone quarry. It’s around 20 by 40 feet and surrounded by huge stone walls on three sides, with a 16-foot waterfall spilling down into it. No fiberglass. No infinity edge trying to look natural. This actually is natural—well, as natural as a repurposed quarry can be.
The landscaping around the pool is clean and simple. Lawn, trees, some well-placed gardens. It’s quiet, private, and totally enclosed. It feels low-key and high-impact at the same time.
Whether you’re swimming, sitting by the edge, or just walking by it on your way to the house—it kind of stops you. You don’t have to imagine how cool it could be. It already is.
The House: Clean, Solid, and Designed to Be Lived In
The house itself is tucked back into the trees and looks like it was designed to fit the land, not fight it. It’s not flashy or overly modern. Instead, it’s thoughtful, clean, and really well maintained.
The Great Room has tall vaulted ceilings, exposed beams, and a wood stove—nothing overdone, but it feels intentional. French doors open up to a huge screened porch that’s elevated off the ground and surrounded by trees. It’s the kind of porch you’d actually use—big enough for a long table, a few chairs, and room to breathe.
The kitchen is solid. Marble countertops, a farmhouse sink with a detailed apron front (a small thing, but it stands out), and custom cabinets that don’t feel cookie-cutter. It flows right into the dining area so the whole setup feels open without being cavernous.
On the first floor, there’s a primary suite with its own sitting area and a spa-style bathroom. It opens right up to the outdoors, so again, the inside and outside are always connected.
Downstairs are three more bedrooms—one with its own bath and two that share a hallway bath. There’s also a bright workout room that could be an office, studio, or whatever you need it to be. The layout works for families, for guests, or even as a second home that doesn’t require a remodel to make it work.
The Land: 60 Acres of Privacy, Trees, and Potential
The house and pool sit on a full 60 acres, which is pretty rare around here. Most properties this size are way out in the hills or stuck on old farmland. This one has a mix—open lawn, woods, and even some cleared trails. If you want to add a second home, a barn, or just keep it as-is, you’ve got room to work with.
It’s private without being completely off-grid. There’s good cell service, modern utilities, and solid roads. But you’re not going to hear traffic or see another house from your windows. It’s quiet, and it stays that way.
Location Details (Not Just Fluff)
This house is in a spot that’s easy to live with:
- 5 minutes to Mount Everett Regional School
- 5 minutes to Berkshire School
- 15 minutes to Great Barrington
- Under 30 minutes to Catamount Ski Area
- Close to Route 7 for access to NYC (about 2.5 hours) or Boston (about 2.5–3)
You’re near nature—hiking trails, rivers, farmland—but also close to real-life stuff like grocery stores, restaurants, schools, and hospitals.
Why This Property Works (And Who It’s For)
This isn’t for everyone—and that’s what makes it good. It’s for someone who wants privacy without isolation. Someone who appreciates clean, well-done design without needing marble everything. Someone who likes the outdoors but doesn’t want to rough it.
It’s great for:
- A second home that doesn’t need constant work
- A primary home for someone working remotely or with flexible travel
- A family that wants land and space but still needs to be near schools
- Someone looking for long-term potential to build or expand over time
And it’s move-in ready. No big renovation needed. You can show up, put your stuff down, and actually enjoy the place.
Local Highlights You’ll Actually Use
Living here gives you access to some low-key gems:
- Great Barrington – Great food (try Prairie Whale or Agaves Mexican Grill), small shops, and a local movie theater.
- The Mount, Edith Wharton’s Estate – 20 minutes away, cool if you’re into history or architecture.
- Bartholomew’s Cobble – A great hike, especially in the fall.
- Catamount – Ski in the winter, adventure park in the summer.
- Tanglewood – Big-name concerts in the summer, 30–40 minutes away.
Final Take
This isn’t a house that’s trying too hard. It just is what it is: a super private property in the Berkshires with one of the coolest pools you’ll ever see, a house that’s ready to go, and room to make it whatever you want.
If you’re into natural materials, clean design, and land that actually feels useful—not just decorative—this place delivers. No fluff, no frills. Just a rare find that’s already done right.
Disclaimer: Hidden Holms does not own this property, the photos, or the listing. We are not affiliated with the seller or the listing agent. This blog post is for entertainment and educational purposes only. Photo credit to listing agent. If you would like to change the photo credit or remove a listing, please contact me directly.
Listing: Zillow – 232 Giberson Rd, Sheffield, MA
Listing Agent: Jared Kelly (413)854-1504 William Pitt Sotheby’s
Photo Tour:
Leave a comment